Portal: Martin
- For therapist
- How I live
- Always-good advice
- Self-training
- Stuff to meditate on
- Things I struggle with
- #ADHD
- Aliefs
- Understand my memory issues
And these ever-growing lists :)
What links here
- 2023-04-21
- Portal: On my mind
- Portals
And these ever-growing lists :)
If you take time out after some criticism to digest it, and plan to respond eventually – say so early on!
Else it can look like you decided to just ignore them.
An issue with org-roam and many other digital slipboxes: titles are mandatory.
Maybe this suits Jethro and the other developers, and it suited me when I first started. Coming from a world where all files we ever create must be given a title, it wouldn't have occurred to me as something I'd want to live without. Besides, the title was how I used to find those files in the first place. But I found advice by a zettelkasten blogger (maybe it was Alex Keyhayias or Andy Matuschak) to try the original pen-and-paper Luhmann system for at least a while.
With the Luhmann system, most notes lack titles.
Freedom from titles means:
I used to worry about whether to title notes as nouns or as active statements. Matuschak even has ideas about titles as a kind of API…
But suppose that all new notes just got a random number as title unless you deign to re-title it later. And suppose we modify all our commands such as org-roam-node-insert
to use ripgrep for matches in body texts instead of a title search. In a way, we'd treat the bodies as titles to themselves (kind of Logseq-ish!). Any titles matter less since we'd not depend on them to find the right note.
That boils down to a couple of lessons we can learn right now, if we still use mandatory titles:
org-roam-node-find
.